So, have y’all heard that Poland is now the only country in Europe where chemical castration is mandatory for paedophiles, or for people who have been found guilty of raping a close relative who is a minor? The law was actually passed in the Senate back in September – and the vote was almost unanimous: 400 ministers voted to pass the law, one minister voted against it and three others abstained – but it came into full effect yesterday. The government released a statement late last year, right after the law was passed: “The purpose of this action is to improve the mental health of the convict, to lower his libido and thereby to reduce the risk of another crime being committed by the same person” and the country’s Prime Minister, Donald Tusk, said in a separate statement that he supported obligatory castration for paedophiles, whom he branded ‘degenerates’. He said he did not believe “one can use the term ‘human’ for such individuals, such creatures. Therefore I don’t think protection of human rights should refer to these kind of events… I want to introduce in Poland the most rigorous law possible regarding criminals who rape children.” At the time, he was criticised by human rights groups outside of Poland, but he has never apologised for his stance, nor has he retracted his words.
And you know what? Nobody in Poland is the slightest bit disturbed about any of this: a survey done earlier this week shows that about 85% of Poles are totally in favour of the law as it stands; the remaining 15% are generally in favour with a few reservations. The number of people who are actively against the law, or who feel any concern for the human rights of paedophiles, is so minimal that it is almost non-existent. The foreign press is asking slightly muted questions, and international human rights groups are not happy (though it must be said, there have been no major explosive reactions) but within Poland, people are perfectly OK with the whole notion. I find this very interesting, and have spent the past couple of days pondering why that might be.
I mean, imagine that the same thing tried to get passed in the US Congress. Imagine trying to get an almost 100% positive vote to pass a law which says that paedophiles or fathers who rape their own children will be forcibly castrated. Not, you know, physically but chemically. The way it actually works here in Poland is that an offender serves their court-determined prison term, and then six months before they are due for release a group of psychologists, sexologists, psychiatrists and some legal advisers meet with the offender and do rigorous interviews, tests and consultations. Based on this, this group of people then decides if chemical castration will take place. If so, treatment (which is a series of medical procedures which lower the libido) begins just before the person is released from jail; if not, I have no idea what happens, but I assume that this person will be monitored as any other sex offender who has been returned to the community at large: they will have to report to a parole officer and they are not free to leave their town or city, and they are not permitted to be within a certain distance of schools, parks, etc.
In some countries, like the Czech Republic and even Canada, chemical castration is undergone voluntarily by people who fully recognise that they are sick, and they have no control over their physical urges, and they are often dismayed and horrified at the fact that they hurt children in order to satisfy a destructive addiction. These people (and they are almost always men) want to be castrated, so they can have a normal life and not rape society’s most vulnerable. A cynic might argue that they also voluntarily take the drugs so they can get better terms of release, or earlier parole, or whatever. I don’t really care about their motivations as much as the effects, which are that these men stop abusing and raping kids. I can get behind that. Interestingly, a number of American states give courts the option of imposing a sentence involving chemical castration, and in some states the punishment is mandatory under certain circumstances. But this is not nation-wide: it comes down to individual states.
I was stunned to hear that paedophilia is a major societal problem here in Poland: apparently 700 cases of paedophilia are reported to police in Poland each year, according to justice officials. I am not amazed at the fact that it happens – because it happens everywhere – but at the fact that it is simply not discussed here. The media does not shout inky columns of protest; lawyers and police officers do not demand help or resources to cope with the issue; there is no raging debate about ‘castration vs rehabilitation’ in the treatment of paedophiles. The assumption, generally, is that once a sick f*** who will rape kids, always a sick f*** who will rape kids – and no amount of talking or therapy or rationality will ever change such a person into an unsick non-f*** who will not rape kids.
Personally, I am of two minds about this. First, I admit to being disturbed at the thought of a group of Polish ‘professionals’ (and I use this word very ironically, as I have had personal experience with the legal, medical and judicial systems here and I know all too well what kind of idiots are running these shows) making such a decision. I also feel that some – maybe many – paedophiles would actually agree to be chemically castrated of their own free will, if given the option; that has been shown in other countries. Finally, I am relieved that the process is ‘reversible’, meaning that when the drug is no longer administered, the person’s body chemistry returns to normal. Maybe with an aggressive combination of drugs and therapy and support, paedophiles can learn to control their urges without the drugs, and so may go off the treatment after some time. Who knows?
On the other hand: I am a mother and if anyone touched my kids I would want to kill them with my bare hands, their uncontrollable illness be damned. If some man so much as TOUCHED Max or Alex – God, it makes me sick to even think about it – you’d better believe I’d want the bastard castrated (chemically or otherwise). Of course that’s an emotional, Mama Lion response, but how else is a parent to respond? It’s my job to keep my children safe. That’s what I signed up for, right?
What are your thoughts on mandatory chemical castration?